Share Post
Cranlana moderator Jacqueline Stone reflects on our recent Emerging Leaders Colloquium, and what Plato’s image of the Great Beast can teach modern leaders about the difference between reading the room and judging what is right.

The recent Cranlana Colloquium for Emerging Leaders was a powerful reminder of the value of shared intellectual enquiry. It brought together a really diverse cohort of creatives and professionals across generations and backgrounds, creating a rich environment for exploring questions that have occupied philosophers for millennia.

The experience was made all the richer by working alongside my co-moderator, Adjunct Professor John Fenwick. A former Australian Army Brigadier, helicopter pilot and commander of units including coalition forces on operations, John knows something about exercising judgment when the stakes are high and decisions have consequences for others.

John’s operational experience brought a valuable practical dimension to the cohort’s philosophical discussions, reminding us that ethical leadership is not simply a matter of knowing what is right, but of deciding what to do when circumstances are difficult and competing demands pull in different directions. He was a terrific colleague with whom to explore these enduring questions.

 

This diversity proved vital as we grappled with the foundational questions of Western philosophy on Day One of the Emerging Leaders Colloquium. Engaging with Socrates, Plato and Aristotle, we explored the universal themes of:

What is human nature?
What makes a good life?
Why be good?

These questions are timeless, but what struck our cohort was how contemporary they felt.

Were these thinkers remarkably prescient, or are the challenges we face today simply more enduring than we realise?

This resonance was clearest when we tackled Plato’s famous allegory of the “Great Beast” in
The Republic. In his vivid imagery, Plato describes a massive, temperamental wild animal representing public opinion or “the crowd”. He critiques those who become experts in studying the beast’s moods, what angers it, what placates it, and what noises it makes. Rather than learning to judge whether the beast is right, they learn to anticipate its reactions and satisfy its demands. They mistake popularity for wisdom and public approval for moral understanding.

The danger, Plato suggests, is that we prepare people for leadership by teaching them to mirror the crowd’s opinions rather than to question them. They become adept at reading the room, but not necessarily at judging what is right.

It is a vivid image, and an uncomfortable one. Substitute public opinion, social media, organisational culture or the prevailing mood for the beast, and the metaphor hardly needs updating.

Our discussions at the Colloquium yielded two important insights:

image c/o allposters.com

First, our modern era of fractured public discourse and digital echo chambers may not be as unprecedented as we imagine. The technologies have changed, but the temptation to follow the crowd, seek approval and avoid dissent is hardly new. Engaging with thinkers who grappled with these problems 2,500 years ago is not merely an academic exercise, it is an urgent requirement for navigating contemporary leadership.

Second, we should resist viewing the past through too narrow a prism. These philosophers were ancient Greek men living in a slave-owning society. Their world was profoundly different from that of a modern, multicultural nation, and their assumptions cannot be adopted wholesale. Yet their limitations do not make every question they asked irrelevant. If someone 2,500 years ago was already warning us about the dangers of substituting public opinion for a considered understanding of right and wrong, we owe it to ourselves to listen, reflect and ask more.

The Colloquium reminded me why philosophy matters. Not because ancient thinkers have all the answers, but because the right questions can unsettle us, sharpen our judgement and help us see our own world differently. And because, occasionally, a beast described in ancient Athens turns out to look remarkably familiar.

If Jacqueline’s reflection has you asking your own questions about public opinion, courage and how to judge what is right, our flagship program, the Cranlana Colloquium, will be a valuable investment for you and your leadership development. Find out more here:

Elevate your leadership with ethical clarity

Discover programs designed to help you lead with purpose, integrity, and confidence in complex environments.

Related Articles

  • Ancient Greek philosophers mosaic in discussion.

    Calming the Beast: What 2,500-year-old philosophers can teach modern leaders

    Oct 29 2026

  • Animated sun, clouds, stars in blue sky.

    Defying Gravity

    Oct 14 2026

  • View of red sandstone canyon against sky

    When Ethics Goes Wrong: The Heuristics Behind Bad Decisions

    Oct 8 2026